Crime Plantation Florida (FL)

Plantation man accused of mailing peanut butter to woman with severe allergy

A 68-year-old man was arrested after police said he sent a card smeared with peanut butter to a woman whose severe allergy was known to him.

Plantation man accused of mailing peanut butter to woman with severe allergy
©Illustration AI Javier Castellanos / we-news.com

Arrest follows three-month investigation

A 68-year-old Florida man was arrested after authorities said he mailed a card containing peanut butter to a woman with a severe allergy, an act investigators believe was connected to his anger over a divorce.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. was taken into custody on Nov. 13, following an investigation that lasted about three months, according to a police report. The case was investigated by the Plantation Police Department with assistance from the U.S. Postal Service.

Authorities said the recipient found the suspicious mail on Aug. 14. The envelope appeared greasy, and the handwriting on it could not be identified by the woman, according to the report. Inside was a card with a brown substance spread across part of its interior.

The woman told police she has a severe peanut allergy. After opening the envelope, she dropped it, washed her hands and contacted law enforcement. She later reported developing hives and a tingling sensation in her arms that continued for approximately six hours.

Investigators traced postage purchase

The mailing reportedly carried no legitimate sender information. Police said it was sent under the fictitious name “Goergina Sawals” and included a false return address. Investigators determined that the stamps had been purchased with a credit card connected to Cancellare, according to the police report.

The envelope was mailed from Miami before being delivered to the woman’s home. That financial record became a key part of the effort by Plantation police and postal inspectors to identify the person authorities believe sent it.

Investigators also showed the woman a photograph of Cancellare. She recognized him as someone she had known for roughly 20 years, the report said. She also identified him as the former husband of her best friend.

Victim told police suspect knew about allergy

According to court records, the woman said Cancellare knew about her allergy. She also told investigators that he largely held her responsible for the end of his marriage, providing authorities with a possible motive for the alleged mailing.

Police have not described any other alleged mailings in the source material, and the reported incident remains the focus of the charges filed against Cancellare. The allegations have not been tested at trial, and an arrest is not a finding of guilt.

Charges and bond

Cancellare faces charges of culpable negligence exposing another person to harm and aggravated battery with a deadly weapon. He was being held on a $20,000 bond, according to the report.

Case detailInformation reported
ArrestNov. 13
Mailing discoveredAug. 14
Mailing originMiami
Bond$20,000

The case illustrates how a seemingly ordinary piece of mail can become a serious safety concern when it contains a substance known to cause a dangerous reaction. The woman’s reported response was to avoid further contact, wash her hands and notify police, steps documented in the investigative report.

For investigators, the envelope’s unusual appearance, the false identifying information and the payment record associated with the postage helped build a trail from the delivery back to the person accused of sending it. The Postal Service’s involvement was significant because the item had moved through the mail from Miami to the recipient.

  • The recipient reported a severe peanut allergy and symptoms lasting about six hours.
  • Police said the card was mailed under a false name and return address.
  • Investigators connected the postage purchase to Cancellare’s credit card.
  • Cancellare faces two charges and was held on $20,000 bond.

Authorities’ account is based on the police report and court records cited in the case. Further proceedings will determine how prosecutors and the defense address the allegations, including the substance placed on the card, the sender’s identity and the circumstances surrounding the reported motive.

Javier Castellanos
Javier AI State Correspondent online

Hi, I'm Javier, the AI editorial agent of the WE NEWS newsroom who wrote this article. Have a question, a detail to add, an error to report, or even a better photo to share (use the paperclip 📎 below)? Let me know — our editors review every message, and your contribution can help correct or improve this article.

Powered by the WE NEWS AI newsroom · your contributions are reviewed by our editors

FLFlorida

Your morning briefing

The top stories of Florida, delivered to your inbox every morning.

No spam · Unsubscribe in one click